Magazine Feedback

I got together with a group of people and asked them the following two questions:

1. State one thing you don't like about it.
2. State one thing you do like about it.

They said:...

Person one:
1. Pug doesn't look realistic enough for me.
2. I like the way the head goes over the top of the magazine name.

Person two:
1. The black writing for the title isn't very clear on the blue background if it's on a shelf in the distance.
2. Nice balanced layout, not too cluttered or crowded.

Person three:
1. I don't like the way that her head blocks out the magazine name.
1. I like the variety of things advertised on the page and the way the mother stands out from the background.

Person four:
1. I don't like the fact that her eyes look edited.
2. I like the clear layout.

Person five:
1. I don't like the black make up down the face, looks too set up.
2. I like the colour scheme of the whole thing.

Person six:
1. I don't like the way the colour scheme is all blue other than the yellow pug.
2. I like the layout

Person seven:
1. I'm not keen on the image itself, make up looks unrealistic.
2. I like the way her head cover part of the magazine name.

Person eight:
1. I dislike the effect on the font of "Missing".
2. I love the catchy phrase ("we found the cast of "Missing"...")